Getting tired of eating at the same restaurants on Main Street? Whether you’re over the dining hall or just craving something new, Cortland is hiding some seriously underrated eats! You just have to know where to look. Your stomach will thank me later.
Prandium:
With its bright, trendy vibe and cozy atmosphere, it’s the perfect spot for a casual brunch or an iced coffee catch-up with a friend. The menu is full of light bites, from avocado toast to fresh pastries, making it a go-to for both relaxing weekends and low-key homework sessions.
Address: 185 Homer Ave Cortland, New York 13045
Menu website: https://cafeprandium.square.site/s/order/QARVCMWZJGGITS3NIGJ3DT7S?location=11ee900e1857eaf791283cecef6dbab4
Nicky Cs:
If you haven’t been to Nicky Cs yet, you’re missing out! This Italian cuisine is perfect for when you want to order something and take it to go! While they are mainly known for their pizza, they have built-your-own 10-dollar subs, which is a great price for a great portion! They also sell light groceries and desserts like cinnamon roll pizza and deep-fried Oreo pizza!
Address: 12 S. West Street Homer, NY 13077
Menu website: https://nicky-cs.com/menu/
The exchange:
This is the perfect place for you if you’re tired of going to Brix and The Rock! Their modern and chic decor sets the perfect backdrop for a memorable evening with friends, family, or that special someone. The quality of the food, combined with the atmosphere of the welcoming staff, is what makes this restaurant so great.
Not only is there just a restaurant, but a bakery too! Located behind The Exchange restaurant, The Exchange Bakery is a specialty bakery featuring a selection of gluten-free and regular baked goods. The Bakery offers breakfast sandwiches and a small selection of savory dishes for take-away.
Address: 21 North Main St Homer, NY
Menu website: https://exchangehomerny.com/
Rexs Pasta:
Rex’s Pasta is an American Italian restaurant located in Cortland, NY. It might not look like much from the outside, but rex’s is serving up some of the best food in town. They offer a delicious fusion of American and Italian cuisines, Rex’s Pasta is the perfect spot for anyone looking to enjoy a hearty meal in a welcoming and cozy environment.
It’s the kind of place where the prices are low, the portions are huge, and the flavor hits every time. Don’t let the faded sign fool you- this place is YUM!
Address: 1098 State Rt 222 Cortland, NY
Menu website: https://rexspasta.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Rexs-Dinner-Menu_2023-1220.pdf
Super cream:
If you’re craving something sweet, this drive-thru ice cream spot is the perfect place for you! Super Cream is known for its homemade hard ice cream! They carry 36-38 flavors throughout the summer months. They also have 40-plus flavors of soft serve, as well as milkshakes, sundaes, banana splits, and flurries.
Looking for dinner before dessert? Try something off their food menu as well, including, but not limited to, hamburgers, hot dogs, french fries, onion rings, and a grilled cheese menu. Super cream has big indoor and outdoor seating as well, which is the perfect vibe for a nice day out!
Address: 75 N West Street Homer, NY 13077
These spots have become some of my go-tos during my time here, and I hope they’ll become yours too. Next time you’re hungry and want to try something new, skip the usual and give one of these hidden gems a shot—you might just find your new favorite.